Week 5 · games Nov 18–22 · injuries as of Wednesday, November 18

Who Should I Start? Fantasy Basketball Start/Sit

Pick two players and get a straight answer for this week: who is projected for more over the games each has left, how often a lead that size holds up, and who is hurt.

Choose two players

Any of the 402 players with enough games this season to be rated. The answer opens on the pair’s own page, which you can bookmark or share.

Pick two players to see them side by side.

Closest calls this week

Pairs of players whose week projections are nearly level, taken from the players ranked 30 to 160 for the week: rostered in most leagues, but not automatic starts. Each card gives the two projected Yahoo fantasy point totals for the week, then what each is projected for in one game: often it is a better player with fewer games against a lesser one with more.

More close calls

How the call is made

Each player gets a projection for one game (what he has done per minute this season, times the minutes we expect), multiplied by the games his team has left in the fantasy week. A game an injury may cost him counts for less. The higher week total is the pick in a points league; for category leagues the page shows who leads each counting category. How one game’s projection is made and tested is on the projections page.

Every call says how often a lead that size has held up. That comes from 694,039 pairs of players over 24 weeks of 2025-26, checked on 4 weeks of 2026-27 that were held back: when the formula said 57%, the higher-projected player finished ahead 59% of the time; when it said 75%, 75%; when it said 97%, 96%. Four weeks is a small check, and the number assumes both players play the games counted for them.

A small edge is worth little: for one game, when two players were projected within 5 Yahoo points of each other, the higher one scored more only 56% of the time. So below 55% the page calls it a toss-up and does not pretend to know.

Sources: Box scores via BALLDONTLIE, Schedule, injuries and lineups via Fantasy NerdsUpdated with games through Wednesday, November 18

Check next

Frequently asked questions

How does the tool decide who to start?

It projects each player for one game (what he has done per minute this season times the minutes we expect), multiplies by the games his team has left this fantasy week, and counts less for a game an injury may cost him. The player with the higher week total is the pick in a points league. For category leagues it shows who leads in each counting category over the same games.

What does "finished ahead about 60 times in 100" mean?

It is how often a lead of that size has held up. We took every pair of players in the same week of 2025-26 (24 weeks), found how the gap between two projections relates to who actually scored more, and then checked it on 4 weeks of 2026-27 that were held back: when the formula said 57%, the higher-projected player finished ahead 59% of the time; when it said 75%, 75%. Four weeks is a small check, and it assumes both players play the games counted.

How much does a small edge in the projection really matter?

Less than it looks. For a single game, when two players were projected within 5 Yahoo points of each other, the one projected higher scored more only 56% of the time in 2025-26 and 57% in the held-back 2026-27 games. An extra game in the week is usually worth more than a small per-game edge.

Does it account for injuries?

Yes, from the injury report. A player who is out counts no games before his return date. When his next game is today or tomorrow, a questionable or game-time-decision tag counts half of that game, probable three quarters and doubtful a quarter. Rest days are not predicted.

Which scoring does it use?

The pick is made on Yahoo default points scoring, and the page says when ESPN or Sleeper default scoring would flip it. If your league uses categories, read the category line instead.