Officials

Referees: NHL penalties and power plays by referee

Which referees call more, and which let them play? Every NHL referee since 2017-18, measured against what the two teams on the ice would normally produce, so a referee who keeps drawing penalty-prone teams does not look whistle-happy.

Tonight's crews are on Referees Tonight and Power Play Tonight once the NHL posts them.

How much do referees matter?

The full test (one season against the next) runs once every season's crews are loaded. On the 1,747 games loaded so far, true referee differences look small (about ±0.22 power plays per game for both teams combined) and only weakly repeatable (odd vs even games: r = 0.18 across 39 referees). Until it passes, the effects are descriptive only and are not used in the power-play forecast.

Active referees

Effect = power-play opportunities per game (both teams) above or below what the teams were expected to get, shrunk for sample size. It is the referee's own share: his partner changes from game to game and averages out over his games, so a crew's effect is the sum of its two referees'. Coloured when the 90% range excludes zero. Regular season, 30+ games in the last four seasons.

Active NHL referees ranked by power-play effect
RefereeGamesThis seasonPP opps/gmExpectedEffect (90%)Penalties/gmHome PP%
Cody Beach#12233216.636.10+0.630.41 to 0.848.1352%
Michael Markovic#31413206.586.13+0.440.24 to 0.658.0452%
Riley Brace#494496.576.04+0.34-0.01 to 0.688.1150%
Jake Brenk#26640186.246.24+0.320.11 to 0.537.7253%
Stephen Hiff#3384176.075.96+0.24-0.05 to 0.547.3350%
Chris Rooney#5578206.376.25+0.21-0.01 to 0.447.6951%
Kyle Rehman#10646205.926.23+0.20-0.01 to 0.407.4652%
Peter MacDougall#38533195.946.17+0.17-0.04 to 0.387.4251%

Rows 9–28 continue below

Active referees · Rows 9–28 of 42

Active NHL referees ranked by power-play effect, rows 9–28 of 42
RefereeGamesThis seasonPP opps/gmExpectedEffect (90%)Penalties/gmHome PP%
Mike Sullivan#4773145.955.96+0.16-0.15 to 0.477.3251%
Chris Schlenker#3536186.396.21+0.16-0.06 to 0.377.6952%
Gord Dwyer#19607195.956.23+0.14-0.08 to 0.367.3752%
Francois St-Laurent#8564185.886.23+0.12-0.10 to 0.347.2253%
Garrett Rank#7654196.246.23+0.11-0.10 to 0.317.7752%
Graedy Hamilton#4167115.855.98+0.10-0.22 to 0.417.4653%
Francis Charron#6571206.106.24+0.09-0.12 to 0.307.2852%
Brandon Blandina#39391185.776.12+0.08-0.12 to 0.297.3453%
Eric Furlatt#27600215.876.22+0.05-0.16 to 0.267.2351%
Graham Skilliter#24651195.726.21−0.01-0.22 to 0.197.1252%
Jordan Samuels Thomas#37180195.906.17−0.02-0.26 to 0.227.6651%
Frederick L'Ecuyer#17646205.876.23−0.02-0.23 to 0.187.3552%
Pierre Lambert#25587175.896.21−0.02-0.23 to 0.187.3752%
Beau Halkidis#22202195.986.13−0.03-0.29 to 0.237.4952%
Jean Hebert#15583205.966.26−0.03-0.24 to 0.187.6552%
Tom Chmielewski#18642185.916.25−0.04-0.25 to 0.177.2952%
Liam Maaskant#4544155.716.13−0.04-0.38 to 0.307.7152%
Mitch Dunning#2036005.636.09−0.04-0.26 to 0.187.0951%
Brandon Schrader#34347185.786.13−0.04-0.25 to 0.167.3452%
Jon McIsaac#2615195.966.26−0.05-0.26 to 0.167.2452%

Rows 29–42 continue below

Active referees · Rows 29–42 of 42

Active NHL referees ranked by power-play effect, rows 29–42 of 42
RefereeGamesThis seasonPP opps/gmExpectedEffect (90%)Penalties/gmHome PP%
Trevor Hanson#14654205.936.24−0.07-0.28 to 0.137.6754%
Justin Kea#36237195.716.11−0.08-0.30 to 0.147.0851%
Brian Pochmara#1657805.736.24−0.09-0.33 to 0.147.1652%
Corey Syvret#23466195.716.16−0.10-0.31 to 0.117.0251%
Kelly Sutherland#11619185.636.20−0.11-0.32 to 0.097.2651%
Kendrick Nicholson#30653195.856.23−0.14-0.34 to 0.077.3652%
Morgan MacPhee#43109115.426.13−0.21-0.49 to 0.066.8154%
Alex Lepkowski#4434105.096.10−0.23-0.59 to 0.137.0346%
Dan O'Rourke#955505.856.26−0.23-0.47 to 0.017.2352%
Carter Sandlak#29276205.376.12−0.28-0.49 to -0.076.5553%
Wes McCauley#4652205.266.22−0.29-0.49 to -0.086.7152%
Thomas John Luxmore#21648185.746.25−0.32-0.52 to -0.117.0952%
Chris Lee#2855005.426.22−0.35-0.56 to -0.146.7853%
Furman South#13504195.616.18−0.38-0.58 to -0.176.9952%

Other referees since 2017-18

Retired, part-time and new NHL referees
RefereeGamesThis seasonPP opps/gmExpectedEffect (90%)Penalties/gmHome PP%
Ghislain Hebert#2256306.136.27−0.21-0.45 to 0.047.7351%
Steve Kozari#4049206.366.29+0.22-0.07 to 0.517.9553%
Kevin Pollock#3345305.606.31−0.22-0.55 to 0.126.9552%
Justin St. Pierre#1240405.686.28not estimated6.7452%
Marc Joannette#2536705.556.34not estimated6.6353%
Dean Morton#3633505.216.28not estimated6.2553%
Ian Walsh#2932705.686.25not estimated6.9552%
Brad Meier#3430805.906.28not estimated7.1553%
Dan O'Halloran#1321105.596.38not estimated6.7553%
Tim Peel#2020706.156.42not estimated7.2351%
Brad Watson#2314105.746.50not estimated6.9351%
Reid Anderson#4912706.496.19not estimated7.8351%
Conor O'Donnell#418005.216.13not estimated6.4051%
Dave Jackson#86306.146.61not estimated7.7353%
Tom Kowal#326105.646.59not estimated6.7152%
Evgeny Romasko#391106.546.86not estimated7.3653%

Power play data stories

How the game changed, told through the numbers.

All NHL data stories

How we measure referees

  1. Every NHL game since 2017-18 lists its two referees and two linesmen. We store the crew for each game and the power-play opportunities and penalties each team got.
  2. For each game we compute how many power plays the two teams were expected to get before the game, from their season-to-date penalty-drawing and penalty-taking rates (the same model as the PP forecast). The referee is credited with the difference: more or fewer power plays than those two teams would normally produce.
  3. A referee's effect is that average difference, shrunk toward zero by an amount the data choose: with dozens of partners, partner effects average out, and the shrinkage stops a 40-game sample from crowning anyone. The interval is a 90% range.
  4. Before any of this goes into a forecast we test whether it repeats: odd games vs even games, one season vs the next, and whether last season's effects improve predictions for this season's games.

Data: NHL game-day officials and NHL team power-play and penalty reports, regular season since 2017-18.

FAQ

Which NHL referees call the most penalties?

The table ranks every referee by how many more or fewer power plays their games produced than the two teams would normally get, shrunk for sample size, alongside raw power plays and penalties per game. A referee at the top has called more than expected over a large sample; the interval shows how sure that is.

Do referees really change the number of power plays?

Possibly a little; it is not proven yet. Most of the game-to-game swing in power plays is the teams and plain chance. On the games loaded so far referee differences look small (about ±0.22 power plays a game for both teams) and only weakly repeatable, so read the effect column as a description of past games, not a prediction.

Who is refereeing tonight?

The NHL posts crews close to puck drop. When they are posted, the Power Play Tonight page (/fantasy-hockey/power-play-tonight) lists both referees for every game, with each referee's effect.

Why does a referee have no effect listed?

Referees with few games are shrunk almost all the way to zero, and a referee who only worked as a linesman has no referee games. Effects are estimated on the last four seasons of regular-season games.