Who to start · 2026-27

Jake Guentzel vs Matthew Schaefer

SurgingOn-ice xGF/60 4.40 (was 3.16)
Steady7 P in last 5 (0.80/GP before)

In 2026-27, Matthew Schaefer scored 2.79 fantasy points per game under ESPN default scoring to Jake Guentzel's 2.62.

Guentzel had 26 points in 21 games; Schaefer had 24 in 20 games.

This week Guentzel has 3 games left with 1 soft and 1 tough matchups; Schaefer has 3 left with 2 soft matchups. In ESPN default points scoring we project Schaefer for 7.6 to Guentzel's 7.0 over the games left.

Jake Guentzel has the better number in 20 of the 30 stats both are ranked on.

Guentzel's biggest edges: High-danger chances 61.8%, Plus/minus +15, Expected goals 60.2%.

Schaefer's biggest edges: Transition attempts /60 0.71, Penalty minutes 14, Forecheck xG /60 0.36.

In standard categories (G, A, +/-, PPP, SOG, HIT), the default in Who Should I Start, Matthew Schaefer rates ahead, +11.1 to +7.0 in summed category z-scores.

Role trend over the last 5 games: Guentzel is surging, On-ice xGF/60 4.40 (was 3.16); Schaefer is steady, 7 P in last 5 (0.80/GP before).

  • • Guentzel, last 10 games (Oct 29–Nov 17): 6 G, 8 A, 4 PPP, 29 SOG.
  • • Schaefer, last 10 games (Oct 25–Nov 17): 8 G, 7 A, 4 PPP, 33 SOG.

Tampa Bay Lightning · New York Islanders · Who should I start? · Compare other players

Fantasy value: your scoring

Jake Guentzel

+7.0

category z-score total

Matthew Schaefer

+11.1

category z-score total

Under Standard (6 categories), Matthew Schaefer has the edge (Guentzel wins 1, Schaefer wins 5 of 6 categories).

Per-stat breakdown under Standard (6 categories)
CategoryGuentzelSchaefer
Goals / game0.620.45
Assists / game0.620.75
Plus/minus / game0.710.05
Power-play points / game0.380.35
Shots on goal / game2.763.70
Hits / game0.620.70

Per-game rates from the selected sample; blended mixes last season with this season, weighting this season more as games are played. Categories are scored as z-scores against qualified players at the same position. Your scoring choice is shared with Who Should I Start: saved on this device, and on your account when you are signed in.

Head-to-head: Guentzel vs Schaefer

Every event between them in NHL play-by-play, 2025-26 to 2026-27: games against each other, faceoffs, shots on goal, hits and penalties. Regular season and playoffs.

GuentzelSchaefer
1Team record in 4 meetings3
3Points in those games2

Guentzel 2G 1A, 11 SOG · Schaefer 1G 1A, 15 SOG

1Hits on each other0
1Shots blocked by the other0

Guentzel blocked 1 of Schaefer's shots; Schaefer blocked 0 of Guentzel's.

On the ice against each other (Guentzel's side)

19:33 at 5-on-5 over 4 games, 2025-26 to 2026-27, from Guentzel's side

Shot attempts
17–18
48.6%
Expected goals
0.3–0.5
36.2%
Goals
1–1

Games against each other

Games between Jake Guentzel and Matthew Schaefer
DateScoreGuentzelSchaefer
2026-10-10TBL 5–3 NYI2G 0A 4S0G 1A 8S
2025-12-13TBL 2–3 NYI0G 1A 6S1G 0A 2S
2025-12-06TBL 0–2 NYI0G 0A 0S0G 0A 4S
2025-12-02TBL 1–2 NYI0G 0A 1S0G 0A 1S

Every stat, side by side

Season values; bars are percentiles at each player's position (longer is better). Click a stat for its explainer.

GuentzelSchaefer

Fantasy box score

Transition, turnovers & faceoffs, Usage, Special teams & discipline, Luck & trend, NHL EDGE tracking continue below

Every stat, side by side (continued)

GuentzelSchaefer

Special teams & discipline

This week's schedule

Nov 16 to Nov 22. More games usually wins a weekly start/sit. Chips show how many fantasy points the opponent allows to the player's position (soft or tough), the Schedule Edge from rest and travel, and the likely opposing goalie with his save percentage. Projections cover the games left: Edgehalla's rest-of-season rates per game, adjusted for each opponent's scoring allowed, in ESPN default points.

Scored in ESPN default points (G 2, A 1, PPP 0.5, SHP 0.5, SOG 0.1, HIT 0.1, BLK 0.5). Use your league's scoring

Tampa Bay Lightning logo

Jake Guentzel

3games

7.0proj. ESPN default pts

  • Tue, Nov 17 vs WSH2.3 pts
    Opp allows 12th-fewest FP to CLikely vs Logan Thompson (.885)
  • Thu, Nov 19 vs EDM2.0 pts
    Opp allows 3rd-fewest FP to CLikely vs Tristan Jarry (.912)
  • Sun, Nov 22 vs BUF2.7 pts
    Opp allows 10th-most FP to CSchedule edge +11.8 win%Likely vs Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen (.867)
New York Islanders logo

Matthew Schaefer

3games

7.6proj. ESPN default pts

  • Tue, Nov 17 vs CBJ2.6 pts
    Opp allows 8th-most FP to DLikely vs Cam Talbot (.908)
  • Thu, Nov 19 @ WPG2.6 pts
    Opp allows 9th-most FP to DLikely vs Stuart Skinner (.883)
  • Sat, Nov 21 @ DET2.4 pts
    Opp allows 15th-fewest FP to DLikely vs John Gibson (.862)

Player data stories

How the game changed, told through the numbers.

All NHL data stories

FAQ

Should I start Jake Guentzel or Matthew Schaefer in fantasy hockey?
In 2026-27, Matthew Schaefer scored 2.79 fantasy points per game under ESPN default scoring to Jake Guentzel's 2.62. Guentzel had 26 points in 21 games; Schaefer had 24 in 20 games. Check this week's games and your league's scoring in the fantasy panel above, since more games usually decide a weekly start.
Who is better, Jake Guentzel or Matthew Schaefer?
On 2026-27 numbers, Jake Guentzel leads in 20 of 30 stats where both qualify, from scoring and power-play production to on-ice shot share and NHL EDGE tracking.
How have Guentzel and Schaefer done against each other?
In 4 games against each other in our data, Guentzel's team went 1–3. Guentzel had 3 points (2 goals) and Schaefer had 2 (1 goals).

2026-27 regular season from NHL play-by-play, shift charts and NHL EDGE, processed by Edgehalla. Head-to-head covers every loaded season (play-by-play from 2019-20; on-ice matchups from 2025-26).Compare other players →